How Pennsylvania’s New Category 1 Testing Requirements May Affect Your Elevator Maintenance Contract

Pennsylvania’s adoption of ASME A17.1-2016 is changing the way elevators are maintained, tested, and documented throughout the Commonwealth.

One of the most significant changes for building owners is the implementation of annual Category 1 (CAT1) testing.

Almost immediately, we’re hearing the same question from owners across Pennsylvania:

“Is Category 1 testing included in my maintenance contract?”

The honest answer is:

Maybe.

Every maintenance agreement is different.

Some contracts include Category 1 testing.

Some include only portions of the testing.

Others specifically exclude testing, inspections, or the labor required to support them.

Understanding your contract before the first annual test is scheduled can help prevent unexpected costs and misunderstandings.


Why This Matters More Than Ever

Historically, many building owners focused on one semi-annual event:

The elevator inspection.

With Pennsylvania’s updated requirements, owners must now think about:

  • Annual Category 1 testing
  • Testing documentation
  • Scheduling
  • Coordination with inspectors
  • Corrective work identified during testing
  • Record retention

These additional responsibilities make it more important than ever to understand exactly what services your maintenance agreement provides.


Your Maintenance Contract Was Written Before the Rules Changed

Many maintenance agreements currently in effect were negotiated before Pennsylvania adopted its updated code requirements.

As a result, your agreement may never mention:

  • Category 1 testing
  • Maintenance Control Programs (MCPs)
  • Annual testing reports
  • Testing coordination
  • Additional documentation requirements

That doesn’t necessarily mean these services are included—or excluded.

It means you should review the agreement carefully rather than making assumptions.


Five Questions Every Building Owner Should Ask

Before your next renewal, ask your elevator contractor these questions.

1. Is Annual Category 1 Testing Included?

This is the first question to ask.

If the answer is yes, ask:

  • Does that include all elevators?
  • Does it include all regulated lifting devices?
  • Does it include labor?
  • Does it include required documentation?

Don’t stop at a simple “yes.”

Understand exactly what is covered.


2. Who Schedules the Testing?

Someone must coordinate:

  • The maintenance technicians
  • The inspector or witnessing authority (when required)
  • Building access
  • Equipment availability
  • Required documentation

Ask who is responsible for managing this process.

Clearly assigning responsibilities helps avoid missed deadlines.


3. Who Pays for Corrective Repairs?

Category 1 testing may identify deficiencies that require correction before the equipment is considered compliant.

Your contract should make it clear:

  • Which repairs are included?
  • Which are billable?
  • How emergency repairs are handled?
  • Whether replacement parts are covered?

Testing and repairs are two different things.

Knowing where one ends and the other begins is important for budgeting.


4. Who Maintains the Required Records?

Pennsylvania’s updated code places greater emphasis on documentation.

Ask:

  • Who keeps the testing reports?
  • Will copies be provided to the owner?
  • Where are maintenance records stored?
  • How long are records retained?

Remember:

If an insurance claim or lawsuit occurs years later, these records may become extremely important.


5. Is the Maintenance Control Program Included?

Every regulated unit should have a Maintenance Control Program (MCP) appropriate for that equipment.

Ask:

  • Does an MCP exist for every elevator?
  • Is it equipment-specific?
  • Is it reviewed and updated when necessary?
  • Can the owner review it?

Many owners are surprised to learn they have never seen the maintenance program governing their own equipment.


Testing Is Not the Same as Maintenance

This is one of the biggest misconceptions.

Routine maintenance includes activities such as:

  • Lubrication
  • Adjustments
  • Cleaning
  • Routine examinations
  • Minor preventive work

Category 1 testing is different.

It is a prescribed annual performance test of specific safety-related functions required by the Code.

Although your maintenance provider typically performs or assists with the testing, testing should not automatically be assumed to be part of routine maintenance unless your agreement clearly says so.


Don’t Forget About the Inspector

Many owners also assume that the testing fee includes the inspection.

Often, several parties are involved in the overall process, including:

  • The elevator maintenance provider
  • The certified inspector or inspection agency
  • The building owner or manager

Each may have separate responsibilities and, depending on the arrangement, separate fees.

Understanding those roles ahead of time makes budgeting much easier.


Contract Renewal Is the Perfect Time to Review Responsibilities

If your maintenance agreement is approaching renewal, now is an excellent opportunity to review:

  • Testing responsibilities
  • Documentation requirements
  • Scheduling responsibilities
  • Reporting requirements
  • Compliance support
  • Pricing structure
  • Exclusions
  • Additional services

Pennsylvania’s updated code provides a good reason to ensure your contract reflects today’s requirements—not yesterday’s.


Think Beyond Compliance

Category 1 testing shouldn’t simply be viewed as another annual expense.

When used effectively, it becomes valuable management information.

Recurring test results can help owners:

  • Identify developing equipment problems.
  • Measure maintenance effectiveness.
  • Improve budgeting.
  • Support modernization planning.
  • Reduce emergency repairs.

Testing has value well beyond satisfying the Code.


An Independent Contract Review Can Save Money

Maintenance contracts are often renewed year after year with very few changes.

Yet code requirements evolve, equipment ages, and owner needs change.

An independent review can help determine whether your agreement:

  • Clearly defines testing responsibilities.
  • Allocates risk appropriately.
  • Reflects current Pennsylvania requirements.
  • Provides adequate documentation.
  • Includes unnecessary exclusions.
  • Continues to serve your building’s long-term interests.

Sometimes the most valuable change isn’t reducing the monthly maintenance price.

It’s improving the clarity of the agreement.


The Bottom Line

Pennsylvania’s annual Category 1 testing requirements are changing more than the testing schedule.

They’re changing the conversations building owners should be having with their elevator contractors.

Now is the time to understand:

  • What’s included.
  • What’s excluded.
  • Who performs the work.
  • Who maintains the records.
  • Who pays for additional services.
  • How your contract supports ongoing compliance.

The best maintenance contract isn’t simply the lowest-priced contract.

It’s the one that clearly defines responsibilities, minimizes surprises, and supports safe, reliable elevator operation for years to come.


Need an Independent Review of Your Elevator Maintenance Contract?

KDA Elevator Consultants helps building owners throughout Pennsylvania evaluate maintenance agreements, clarify testing responsibilities, review Maintenance Control Programs, oversee Category 1 testing, and ensure contracts align with current code requirements.

Before you renew your agreement—or receive your first Category 1 testing invoice—let us help you understand exactly what your contract provides.

KDA Elevator Consultants

📞 484-995-3642

📧 john@kdaelevatorconsultants.com

Because the Best Time to Understand Your Contract Is Before You Need It.