Is Your Elevator Maintenance Contractor Actually Maintaining Your Equipment?
Why Regular Service Visits Don’t Always Mean Proper Maintenance—and What Building Owners Should Know
Your building has an elevator maintenance contract. A technician visits regularly. You receive monthly invoices, and most of the time, your elevators operate without incident.
But how do you know whether your elevator equipment is actually receiving the maintenance it needs?
For many commercial building owners, condominium associations, and property managers, the answer is surprisingly unclear.
Elevator maintenance is one of the few major building operating expenses where owners routinely pay thousands of dollars annually for specialized services they may have little ability to independently evaluate.
Unlike landscaping, janitorial services, or other visible building maintenance activities, much of the work performed on an elevator takes place behind locked machine room doors, inside hoistways, and within control systems that building personnel cannot safely access or evaluate.
The result is a fundamental challenge: How can an owner determine whether the maintenance contractor is properly maintaining the equipment, or simply responding when something breaks?
Understanding the difference is essential to protecting elevator reliability, minimizing expensive repairs, and managing the equipment’s long-term useful life.
The Difference Between Elevator Maintenance and Elevator Repair
One of the most common misunderstandings among building owners is the assumption that a maintenance contractor responding to service calls is the same as that contractor performing preventive maintenance.
These are two very different activities.
Preventive maintenance involves scheduled examinations, cleaning, lubrication, adjustments, testing, and other equipment-specific procedures intended to keep the elevator operating properly and reduce the likelihood of premature failures.
Corrective maintenance and repairs involve addressing equipment problems after a deficiency has developed or a component has failed.
Both are necessary, but they serve different purposes.
An effective maintenance program should help identify and correct deteriorating conditions before those conditions result in shutdowns, damage, or expensive repairs.
For example, a poorly adjusted elevator door operator may continue functioning for months while placing unnecessary stress on door components.
Eventually, the problem may lead to worn equipment, repeated door faults, and costly repairs.
A properly implemented preventive maintenance program should include appropriate examinations and adjustments intended to identify such conditions before they become significant failures.
The objective of maintenance is not simply to keep the elevator running today. It is to preserve safe, reliable operation throughout the equipment’s useful life.
Just Because a Technician Visits Doesn’t Mean Everything Is Being Maintained
Most elevator maintenance contracts establish some form of scheduled service, but the amount of time spent maintaining the equipment and the specific work performed can vary considerably.
A maintenance visit may include several meaningful preventive maintenance tasks. Alternatively, a technician may spend much of the available time responding to a trouble condition, investigating a callback, or addressing an immediate operational concern.
From the building owner’s perspective, both situations may appear identical.
The technician arrived, accessed the equipment, and departed.
However, the long-term consequences can be very different.
Building owners should understand that the presence of a technician is not, by itself, evidence that all required preventive maintenance tasks were completed.
The more meaningful questions are:
- What maintenance procedures were scheduled?
- Which procedures were actually completed?
- Were equipment deficiencies identified?
- Were necessary adjustments performed?
- Were recommendations communicated to the owner?
- Are recurring problems being investigated and corrected?
- Is the work being documented?
These questions become particularly important as elevator equipment ages and maintenance requirements change.
What Should a Proper Elevator Maintenance Program Include?
Not every elevator requires the same maintenance procedures or service frequency.
A modern machine-room-less traction elevator, a traditional geared traction elevator, and a hydraulic elevator may have substantially different maintenance needs.
An appropriate maintenance program should consider the equipment’s design, age, operating environment, condition, accumulated usage, manufacturer’s requirements, and applicable safety code provisions.
Depending on the equipment, preventive maintenance activities may include:
Door Equipment
Elevator doors are among the most frequently operated mechanical assemblies in a building.
Maintenance activities may include examining and adjusting door operators, rollers, tracks, hangers, guides, door closing devices, interlocks, and associated components.
Improperly maintained door equipment can contribute to nuisance shutdowns, poor door operation, and accelerated component wear.
Machines, Motors, and Brakes
For applicable traction elevators, maintenance should address the condition and operation of machines, motors, brakes, and related equipment.
This may include specified lubrication, examinations, adjustments, and other required maintenance tasks.
Brake-related deficiencies deserve particular attention because these components perform critical functions in controlling and stopping elevator movement.
Controllers and Electrical Equipment
Elevator control systems contain electrical and electronic components that may be affected by deterioration, contamination, environmental conditions, and other factors.
Maintenance activities should follow the applicable equipment-specific procedures for examination, cleaning, adjustment, and verification.
Hydraulic Equipment
Hydraulic elevators require attention to power units, valves, piping, operating performance, fluid condition and levels, and other applicable components.
Changes in leveling performance, unusual operation, leakage, or excessive oil usage may indicate problems requiring further evaluation.
The condition of concealed components, including underground hydraulic cylinders, cannot necessarily be established through routine visual observation.
Hoistway and Pit Equipment
Applicable maintenance activities should address accessible equipment, housekeeping, lubrication requirements, water intrusion, corrosion, and other conditions that could affect safe operation or equipment longevity.
These examples are not a complete maintenance checklist. The actual maintenance requirements must be established for the specific elevator installation.
The Maintenance Control Program: An Important Tool for Accountability
One of the most important components of an effective elevator maintenance system is the Maintenance Control Program (MCP).
Under ASME A17.1, the MCP establishes the procedures, tasks, examinations, tests, and intervals necessary for maintaining covered elevator equipment.
Rather than relying solely on a generic monthly visit, the program is intended to identify the maintenance activities appropriate for the particular installation.
An effective MCP should account for factors such as equipment age, usage, design, condition, operating environment, and applicable manufacturer instructions.
Maintenance records should then provide evidence of the activities performed.
For building owners, these records can help answer a critical question:
Is the contractor performing maintenance according to an established equipment-specific program?
Pennsylvania’s updated elevator regulations, effective December 20, 2026, make understanding applicable maintenance and testing obligations particularly timely.
Owners should work with their maintenance providers to confirm that required maintenance programs and records are properly established and available in accordance with applicable requirements.
Seven Warning Signs Your Elevator May Not Be Receiving Adequate Maintenance
Although identifying improper maintenance requires technical evaluation, certain warning signs should prompt additional questions.
1. Frequent callbacks for the same problem
An occasional service interruption does not necessarily indicate inadequate maintenance.
However, repeated shutdowns involving the same doors, leveling issues, control faults, or other symptoms may suggest that the underlying cause has not been adequately corrected.
Owners should ask whether the contractor is identifying the root cause or repeatedly performing temporary corrective work.
2. Increasing repair expenses
An aging elevator will eventually require repairs.
However, rapidly increasing repair expenses—particularly for components that should be addressed through routine preventive maintenance—may warrant a closer review.
It is also important to evaluate whether the proposed work is covered by the existing maintenance agreement.
3. Incomplete or unavailable maintenance records
An owner should be able to obtain meaningful information about scheduled maintenance activities, completed work, and identified deficiencies.
Records that contain only generic statements such as “checked elevator” may not provide adequate insight into the actual services performed.
The specific documentation required will depend on applicable code requirements and the maintenance arrangement.
4. Recurring inspection deficiencies
If the same inspection findings appear repeatedly, owners should question whether the contractor is adequately addressing the underlying problems.
A recurring deficiency may indicate an unresolved technical issue, a breakdown in communication, or insufficient corrective action.
5. Excessive equipment deterioration
Evidence of neglected lubrication, contamination, corrosion, damaged components, improper adjustments, or poor housekeeping can indicate maintenance deficiencies.
Such conditions require professional evaluation because not every instance of equipment deterioration results from improper maintenance.
6. Lack of proactive recommendations
A good maintenance contractor should be capable of identifying developing equipment concerns and advising the owner when action is necessary.
If recommendations arise only after a major failure, the owner may want to evaluate whether the preventive maintenance program is sufficiently proactive.
7. No meaningful explanation of equipment reliability
When an elevator experiences repeated problems, the owner should receive more than a description of the latest failed component.
Understanding the cause of recurring problems, proposed corrective actions, and the likelihood of future failures is necessary for making informed maintenance and capital decisions.
Why Passing an Elevator Inspection Doesn’t Prove Maintenance Is Adequate
Pennsylvania requires periodic inspections of covered elevator equipment.
Under 34 Pa. Code § 405.7, conventional electric and hydraulic elevators are subject to periodic inspections at intervals not exceeding six months.
These inspections provide an important regulatory safeguard.
However, a routine regulatory inspection and a comprehensive maintenance quality audit serve different purposes.
A regulatory inspection is intended to evaluate compliance with applicable requirements at the time of inspection.
A maintenance audit takes a broader look at the quality and effectiveness of the maintenance program.
For example, an elevator may pass a regulatory inspection while still exhibiting maintenance practices or equipment conditions that could lead to premature wear and future reliability problems.
A maintenance audit may evaluate:
- The condition of major equipment assemblies.
- Evidence of scheduled preventive maintenance.
- Lubrication and adjustment practices.
- Maintenance records and MCP implementation.
- Recurring callbacks and repair history.
- Contractor performance relative to the maintenance agreement.
- Developing equipment deterioration.
- Potentially unnecessary repair expenditures.
- Equipment conditions that could affect future capital requirements.
Passing an inspection is important. But passing an inspection is not the same as demonstrating that an elevator is being maintained effectively.
How Pennsylvania’s New Category 1 Requirements Raise the Stakes
Beginning December 20, 2026, Pennsylvania’s revised elevator regulations introduce expanded periodic testing requirements, including annual Category 1 testing for applicable equipment.
These tests are intended to verify the performance of specified elevator safety systems.
For building owners, this creates an additional opportunity to evaluate whether equipment is being adequately maintained.
Certain deficiencies may remain unnoticed during everyday passenger operation but become apparent when required safety functions are tested.
For example, problems involving emergency operating functions, applicable protective devices, or other required systems may result in unsuccessful testing.
An unsuccessful test does not automatically establish negligence or inadequate maintenance. Nevertheless, deficiencies discovered during testing should prompt an evaluation of their cause and whether appropriate preventive maintenance could have identified them sooner.
Owners should also recognize that Category 1 testing is not a substitute for routine preventive maintenance.
The most effective strategy is to maintain the equipment properly throughout the year rather than attempting to prepare for compliance only immediately before testing.
What Does Poor Elevator Maintenance Actually Cost?
The cost of inadequate maintenance is often much greater than the immediate expense of a failed component.
Consider the following potential consequences:
Increased repairs: Components subjected to excessive wear, improper adjustment, or inadequate lubrication may require replacement earlier than anticipated.
More frequent shutdowns: Recurring service interruptions can affect tenant satisfaction, accessibility, and building operations.
Shortened equipment life: Premature deterioration may increase the likelihood of expensive modernization or equipment replacement.
Unexpected capital expenditures: Owners may be forced to fund major repairs without sufficient budget preparation.
Contract disputes: Ambiguity concerning maintenance obligations can lead to disagreement about repair coverage and additional charges.
Regulatory consequences: Unresolved deficiencies and unsuccessful required testing can create additional compliance expenses and, depending on the circumstances, potential removal from service.
While not every equipment failure is preventable, an effective maintenance program can help reduce avoidable deterioration and better manage the total cost of ownership.
Should You Hire an Independent Elevator Maintenance Consultant?
For many properties, the answer is worth considering—particularly when repair expenses are increasing, shutdowns are recurring, or the owner lacks meaningful visibility into the contractor’s performance.
An independent elevator consultant works on behalf of the property owner rather than the maintenance contractor.
The consultant can evaluate equipment conditions, review maintenance records, examine contract obligations, and provide an objective assessment of maintenance quality.
The objective is not to create an adversarial relationship with the elevator contractor.
In fact, effective independent oversight can improve communication between the contractor and property owner by establishing clearer expectations, identifying priorities, and helping both parties address issues before they become significant problems.
An annual maintenance quality audit can provide owners with an independent assessment of the condition of their equipment and the effectiveness of the services they are purchasing.
From Maintenance Audits to Comprehensive Elevator Asset Management
For owners interested in a more proactive approach, maintenance audits can become part of a comprehensive elevator asset management program.
Rather than addressing inspections, repairs, contractor performance, and capital planning independently, an integrated program brings these functions together.
A comprehensive program may include:
- Semiannual regulatory elevator inspections.
- Category 1 and Category 5 test witnessing, as applicable.
- Annual independent maintenance quality audits.
- Maintenance contract administration.
- Repair proposal evaluation.
- Invoice and expenditure analysis.
- Regulatory compliance tracking.
- Equipment condition assessments.
- Long-term capital planning.
- Independent owner advisory services.
This approach provides a more complete understanding of elevator performance and ownership costs.
It also allows problems identified during inspections or maintenance audits to be tracked through corrective action, repair evaluation, and future capital planning.
How KDA Elevator Consultants Can Help
At KDA Elevator Consultants, we believe elevator owners deserve more than a maintenance contract and a monthly invoice.
They deserve independent information about the condition of their equipment, the services they are receiving, and the expenditures necessary to preserve their assets.
KDA provides Pennsylvania elevator inspections, periodic test witnessing, maintenance audits, contract reviews, repair proposal evaluations, and comprehensive elevator asset management consulting.
Our services are designed to help building owners and property managers:
- Understand whether their elevator equipment is being properly maintained.
- Identify conditions contributing to recurring repairs and shutdowns.
- Evaluate maintenance contractor performance.
- Review the reasonableness of proposed repairs and invoices.
- Prepare for regulatory inspections and testing.
- Develop realistic capital plans for aging equipment.
Our objective is to help owners maintain safer, more reliable elevator equipment while making informed decisions about maintenance, repairs, and long-term investments.
The Bottom Line
If your elevator contractor visits regularly and your elevators generally operate, it may be tempting to assume that everything is being properly maintained.
But regular service visits alone do not establish the quality or effectiveness of a preventive maintenance program.
The better question is whether the maintenance being performed is appropriate for the equipment, properly documented, and effective at identifying problems before they lead to breakdowns.
Elevator maintenance should be measured by more than the number of service visits. It should be evaluated by the condition of the equipment, the quality of the work performed, and the long-term reliability of the asset.
For owners who want greater transparency and accountability, an independent maintenance audit can be an important first step.
Do You Know Whether Your Elevators Are Being Properly Maintained?
KDA Elevator Consultants provides independent elevator maintenance audits, regulatory inspections, and comprehensive asset management services throughout Pennsylvania.
Whether you manage one building or an entire portfolio, we can help you better understand your elevator equipment and the services you are paying for.
KDA Elevator Consultants
Phone: 484-995-3642
Email: john@kdaelevatorconsultants.com
Website: www.kdaelevatorconsultants.com
Contact KDA to discuss an independent elevator maintenance audit or comprehensive asset management program.