How to Prepare Your Elevator for Pennsylvania’s New Category 1 Testing Requirements

10 steps every building owner should take to reduce the risk of failed testing, unexpected repairs, and prolonged elevator downtime.

December 20, 2026, marks an important change for Pennsylvania elevator owners.

With the Commonwealth’s adoption of updated elevator safety regulations incorporating ASME A17.1-2016, annual Category 1 testing will become a more significant part of ongoing elevator compliance.

For building owners and property managers, the question is no longer simply whether their elevators are operating properly.

The more important question is:

Will your elevator be ready when its required safety testing takes place?

An elevator may operate reliably for years while having deficiencies in safety devices that are rarely activated during normal operation.

Those deficiencies may not become apparent until formal testing occurs.

When a required safety device fails, the consequences can range from a relatively simple adjustment to a prolonged shutdown involving replacement parts, engineering, regulatory approvals, and additional inspections.

The good news is that building owners can take meaningful steps to prepare.

Here are ten things every Pennsylvania building owner should do before Category 1 testing begins.


1. Understand What Type of Elevator You Own

Not every elevator is tested in exactly the same way.

The required tests depend on the elevator’s design, equipment, and applicable code provisions.

Most commercial elevators fall into three general categories.

Hydraulic Elevators

Hydraulic elevators use pressurized hydraulic fluid to raise the elevator car.

Depending on the equipment, Category 1 testing includes prescribed evaluations of hydraulic safety functions, including pressure-related protective devices.

Owners should pay particular attention to the condition of hydraulic control equipment, relief valves, piping, and other components associated with safe operation.

Roped-Hydraulic Elevators

Roped-hydraulic elevators use hydraulic power in combination with suspension ropes and sheaves.

Because of this arrangement, they may incorporate additional safety systems not found on conventional direct-acting hydraulic elevators.

These can include governors, car safeties, and other protective devices.

Their testing requirements must account for the actual equipment configuration.

Traction Elevators

Traction elevators use an electric driving machine, suspension system, and typically a counterweight.

Depending on the installation, required testing can involve electrical protective devices, braking-related safety functions, and other applicable systems.

Owners should understand that some governor, brake, and car safety performance tests are assigned to different testing categories.

The first step in preparing for testing is knowing what equipment you own and which tests actually apply.


2. Review Your Previous Elevator Inspection Reports

Before scheduling testing, gather your previous inspection reports.

Look for:

  • Outstanding violations.
  • Previously identified safety concerns.
  • Recurring deficiencies.
  • Conditions requiring monitoring.
  • Items that were repaired but have not been adequately documented.

An inspection report can provide valuable insight into the condition of the elevator.

If an inspector previously identified a deteriorated component, improper adjustment, or other safety concern, that issue should be reviewed before testing.

Owners should also verify that previously cited deficiencies were properly corrected.

A known deficiency should never be ignored simply because the elevator continues operating.


3. Confirm That Your Maintenance Control Program Is Being Followed

The Maintenance Control Program, commonly referred to as the MCP, is an important component of ASME A17.1 Section 8.6.

It establishes the framework for maintaining equipment based on its design, operating conditions, and applicable requirements.

Before testing, ask your maintenance contractor:

  • Does an MCP exist for this elevator?
  • Is it appropriate for the actual equipment?
  • Are the prescribed maintenance tasks being performed?
  • Are required examinations and tests documented?
  • Have identified deficiencies been corrected?
  • Are maintenance records available for review?

A maintenance contract and an MCP are not the same thing.

The maintenance contract establishes the commercial relationship between the owner and contractor.

The MCP addresses the technical maintenance requirements for the equipment.

Both deserve attention.


4. Have Your Maintenance Contractor Evaluate Critical Safety Components

This may be one of the most important steps.

Certain elevator safety devices are rarely activated during normal operation.

Consequently, an elevator can appear to function properly even when a protective device requires adjustment, repair, or replacement.

Before formal testing, owners should ask their maintenance contractor whether known safety-related deficiencies have been evaluated.

Depending on the elevator, areas of concern may include:

  • Hydraulic pressure relief valves.
  • Electrical protective devices.
  • Braking components.
  • Governor-related protective functions.
  • Terminal stopping devices.
  • Safety circuits.
  • Other applicable protective systems.

Any technical examination, adjustment, or preliminary functional evaluation must be performed by qualified elevator personnel using appropriate procedures.

The goal is not to guarantee a passing test. It is to identify and correct known problems before they become unexpected failures.

A pre-testing review does not replace the required witnessed Category 1 test.


5. Determine Whether Your Equipment Contains Obsolete Components

This is especially important for older elevators.

Many Pennsylvania buildings operate elevators that were installed decades ago.

Some have been modernized.

Others continue operating with original controllers, hydraulic valves, braking systems, and electrical equipment.

Over time, manufacturers discontinue replacement parts and technical support.

Ask your maintenance contractor:

  • Are any critical components obsolete?
  • Are replacement parts still manufactured?
  • Are compatible replacement components available?
  • Are specialized service tools required?
  • Would a component failure require a major modification or modernization?

Consider an older traction elevator with a controller that is no longer supported by its manufacturer.

If a required safety function fails during testing, the problem may not be limited to the failed component.

The owner may discover that the necessary replacement is unavailable.

An engineered solution or controller replacement may become necessary.

That can introduce equipment lead times, engineering work, regulatory review, and additional testing.

The worst time to discover that a critical component is obsolete is after the elevator has already been removed from service.

Obsolescence alone does not constitute a Category 1 testing failure. The concern is whether a failed safety function can be restored using an acceptable repair or replacement solution.


6. Review Your Elevator Maintenance Contract

Many building owners assume that Category 1 testing is included in their maintenance agreement.

That assumption can lead to unexpected expenses.

Before testing, determine:

  • Is Category 1 testing included in the contract?
  • Is technician labor included?
  • Who schedules the testing?
  • Who prepares and maintains the documentation?
  • Are corrective repairs covered?
  • Are replacement parts included?
  • Are additional visits or retesting billable?

Some agreements include periodic testing.

Others exclude it or provide only limited coverage.

A contract may also distinguish between routine maintenance, code-required testing, repairs, replacements, and alterations.

Understanding those differences before testing helps owners budget and avoid disputes.


7. Coordinate With Building Personnel and Other Contractors

Some elevator testing and related compliance activities require cooperation from other building systems.

Depending on the equipment and the required testing, coordination may involve:

  • Building engineering personnel.
  • Fire alarm contractors.
  • Emergency generator service providers.
  • Electrical contractors.
  • Security personnel.
  • Property management staff.

For example, certain fire service or emergency power functions may require coordinated testing or verification under their applicable requirements.

These activities should be distinguished from the specific Category 1 tests prescribed for the elevator.

Owners should confirm in advance which building systems must be available and which contractors need to participate.

Poor coordination can lead to canceled appointments, additional charges, and unnecessary delays.


8. Schedule Testing Before the Deadline

Pennsylvania’s revised regulations require Category 1 testing at the prescribed annual interval for applicable equipment.

Under 34 Pa. Code § 405.8, the required testing must be witnessed by a construction code official.

That means scheduling may involve both the elevator contractor and an appropriately certified inspector.

Waiting until the last minute creates unnecessary risk.

If the elevator requires repairs before testing, additional time may be necessary.

If replacement parts are unavailable, the delay may be considerably longer.

And if the inspector or contractor cannot accommodate the preferred date, scheduling becomes another challenge.

Building owners should establish a testing calendar and coordinate with their maintenance provider well in advance.

The Department of Labor & Industry should be consulted for applicable transition guidance and scheduling requirements.


9. Understand What Happens If the Elevator Fails

Not every failed test produces the same outcome.

Some deficiencies can be corrected relatively quickly.

Others may require substantial repairs.

Serious safety-related conditions may prevent continued operation until corrective action is completed.

If the required work constitutes a major repair, replacement, or alteration, Pennsylvania’s regulations may require the elevator to remain out of service until the prescribed process is completed.

Under 34 Pa. Code § 405.10, major repairs, replacements, and alterations trigger specific notification, inspection, and return-to-service requirements.

Depending on the corrective work, the process may involve:

  • Engineering evaluation.
  • Replacement-part procurement.
  • Permit applications where required.
  • Regulatory review.
  • Repair or alteration work.
  • Required testing.
  • Inspection and approval before returning to service.

This can significantly extend the total duration of a shutdown.

A repair that requires only a few days of physical work may result in weeks of downtime when equipment availability, paperwork, approvals, and inspections are involved.

Owners should understand these possibilities before testing begins—not after a failure occurs.


10. Develop a Contingency Plan for Unexpected Downtime

What happens if your elevator cannot return to service immediately?

For a building with multiple elevators, the remaining units may provide limited alternative transportation.

For a building with only one elevator, the consequences can be much more serious.

Consider the impact on:

  • Accessibility.
  • Tenants and residents.
  • Deliveries.
  • Building operations.
  • Patient transportation.
  • Hotel guests.
  • Emergency planning.
  • Business continuity.

Property managers should identify potential operational challenges and determine how they would respond to an extended shutdown.

Depending on the building, temporary accommodations or alternative arrangements may be necessary.

A contingency plan cannot eliminate the consequences of a failed test.

But it can help reduce confusion and improve communication when unexpected problems occur.


A Special Concern for Older Pennsylvania Elevators

Older equipment deserves particular attention.

A building may have an elevator that has operated reliably for 30 or 40 years.

That does not necessarily mean its safety devices are in acceptable condition or that replacement parts remain available.

Category 1 testing may identify problems that have not previously affected everyday operation.

For these buildings, preparation should include more than simply scheduling the required test.

Owners should consider a broader evaluation of:

  • Equipment condition.
  • Maintenance history.
  • Obsolete components.
  • Reliability trends.
  • Future capital requirements.
  • Modernization needs.

In some cases, the most cost-effective long-term decision may be to address aging equipment before a critical failure forces an emergency project.


The Value of an Independent Pre-Testing Assessment

An independent elevator consultant can help owners evaluate potential risks before required testing begins.

This is particularly valuable when:

  • The elevator is more than 20 years old.
  • Major components are obsolete.
  • Maintenance records are incomplete.
  • The building has experienced recurring elevator problems.
  • Previous inspections identified deficiencies.
  • The owner is uncertain about maintenance contract coverage.
  • An extended shutdown would significantly disrupt operations.

A pre-testing assessment may include an equipment inventory, review of maintenance and inspection records, evaluation of known deficiencies, assessment of obsolescence concerns, and recommendations for corrective action.

The objective is to help the owner understand the condition of the equipment and make informed decisions.

It is not a substitute for required maintenance, testing, or inspection.


The Bottom Line: Preparation Is Less Expensive Than Surprise

Pennsylvania’s updated elevator testing requirements represent an important change in how building owners must manage compliance.

But the greatest challenge may not be the annual test itself.

It may be discovering an equipment problem that should have been addressed months or years earlier.

A failed safety device, obsolete controller component, or deteriorated hydraulic system can create significant costs and prolonged downtime.

Building owners who prepare in advance can reduce avoidable surprises.

That means knowing what equipment they own, understanding their maintenance history, identifying obsolete components, reviewing contract coverage, and developing a contingency plan.

The best time to prepare for Category 1 testing is while your elevator is still operating—not after it has been taken out of service.


Is Your Elevator Ready for Pennsylvania’s New Category 1 Testing Requirements?

KDA Elevator Consultants helps Pennsylvania building owners prepare for required elevator testing through independent equipment assessments, maintenance audits, compliance reviews, testing oversight, and long-term capital planning.

Whether you own one elevator or manage an entire portfolio, we can help identify potential risks before they become costly problems.

KDA Elevator Consultants

Independent Expertise. Objective Guidance. Better Elevator Decisions.

Phone: 484-995-3642
Email: john@kdaelevatorconsultants.com

Contact KDA Elevator Consultants to discuss your elevator’s testing readiness and compliance strategy.