10 Common Deficiencies That Can Cause an Elevator to Fail Category 1 Testing in Pennsylvania
What building owners should know before annual testing reveals an expensive problem.
Your elevator may be operating normally today. Passengers enter, select their floor, and arrive without incident.
But does that mean the elevator will pass its required Category 1 safety test?
Not necessarily.
As Pennsylvania prepares to implement its updated elevator safety regulations on December 20, 2026, building owners face an important question:
Is my elevator actually ready for the new testing requirements?
Under Pennsylvania’s updated regulations, applicable elevators will be subject to annual Category 1 testing in accordance with ASME A17.1-2016. Testing must be witnessed by a certified construction code official.
For many buildings, this introduces a more structured annual testing process.
And for older elevators, particularly those with deferred maintenance or obsolete equipment, testing could uncover deficiencies that have existed for years.
Some problems may be relatively easy to correct.
Others could result in significant repairs, unexpected expenses, and prolonged elevator downtime.
Here are ten areas building owners should understand before their next Category 1 test.
1. Hydraulic Pressure Relief Valves That Do Not Operate Properly
Equipment affected: Hydraulic and roped-hydraulic elevators
Hydraulic elevators rely on pressurized oil to raise the elevator car.
A pressure relief valve is an important safety component designed to prevent excessive hydraulic system pressure.
During the applicable Category 1 testing, the relief valve and system pressure are evaluated to verify compliance with prescribed requirements.
Problems may include:
- Improper relief valve adjustment.
- A valve that does not open at the required pressure.
- A valve that cannot adequately relieve pump output.
- Deteriorated or malfunctioning valve components.
- Evidence of unauthorized adjustments.
A hydraulic elevator may continue operating even when the pressure relief valve is improperly adjusted.
Why owners should be concerned: A failed relief valve test may require adjustment, repair, or replacement. On older equipment, replacement valve components may be obsolete or difficult to obtain.
2. Hydraulic System Leakage or Inability to Maintain Test Pressure
Equipment affected: Hydraulic and roped-hydraulic elevators
Hydraulic elevators depend on the integrity of their cylinders, piping, fittings, and related components.
Applicable Category 1 testing includes prescribed evaluations of hydraulic system integrity.
A system that cannot maintain the required conditions during testing may indicate leakage or another deficiency.
Potential causes include:
- Deteriorated seals or packing.
- Leaking hydraulic piping or fittings.
- Internal leakage.
- Corrosion or deterioration of hydraulic components.
- Problems with the cylinder or associated equipment.
Some leaks are readily visible.
Others may be concealed within the hydraulic system or below ground.
This is particularly concerning for older elevators with buried hydraulic cylinders.
Why owners should be concerned: A suspected cylinder problem can require substantial investigation. If replacement becomes necessary, the cost and downtime may be significant.
A routine annual test could be the event that reveals a much larger capital expense.
3. Elevator Braking Systems That Do Not Perform as Required
Equipment affected: Primarily traction elevators
Traction elevators rely on mechanical braking systems to control and hold the elevator.
Although an elevator may stop normally during everyday operation, that does not necessarily establish that all applicable braking safety functions will perform as required.
Potential deficiencies include:
- Excessively worn brake linings.
- Improper brake adjustment.
- Deteriorated brake components.
- Brake monitoring deficiencies.
- Malfunctioning electrical controls.
- Inadequate brake maintenance.
The precise Category 1 brake-related tests depend on the elevator’s design, equipment, and applicable code requirements.
Why owners should be concerned: Brake deficiencies can be serious safety concerns. Some can be corrected through proper maintenance, while others may require replacement components or more extensive work.
On older traction elevators, obsolete brake components or control systems can complicate the repair.
4. Governor and Overspeed Protective Device Deficiencies
Equipment affected: Traction and certain roped-hydraulic elevators
Elevator governors are important components of the safety system.
Depending on the elevator design, governors and associated protective devices help detect overspeed conditions and initiate prescribed protective actions.
Potential problems include:
- Improper governor switch operation.
- Deteriorated electrical contacts.
- Mechanical binding.
- Contamination or inadequate lubrication.
- Excessive wear.
- Improper adjustment.
- Deteriorated governor ropes or associated components.
Not every governor performance test is a Category 1 test. Some mechanical overspeed and safety performance tests are assigned to longer testing intervals.
However, applicable annual electrical protective device testing can reveal governor-related deficiencies.
Why owners should be concerned: A governor-related failure may require specialized repair, adjustment, or replacement.
For older equipment, finding compatible replacement parts may be challenging.
5. Door Interlocks and Electrical Protective Devices
Equipment affected: Hydraulic, roped-hydraulic, and traction elevators
Elevator doors incorporate important protective devices intended to prevent unsafe operation.
Hoistway door interlocks and related electrical contacts help ensure the elevator does not operate under prohibited door conditions.
Potential deficiencies include:
- Worn or damaged interlock components.
- Improperly adjusted contacts.
- Deteriorated wiring.
- Defective door-locking mechanisms.
- Unauthorized bypasses.
- Damaged or missing protective components.
Door equipment is also subject to routine inspection and maintenance requirements.
Importantly, not every door-related deficiency is discovered through a prescribed Category 1 test. Some are identified during routine inspection or maintenance examinations.
Why owners should be concerned: Door equipment receives frequent use and can deteriorate over time.
A building with recurring door problems should not assume those issues will disappear simply because the elevator continues operating.
6. Emergency Terminal Stopping and Protective Devices
Equipment affected: Primarily traction elevators, depending on design
Elevators incorporate protective devices intended to prevent unsafe travel beyond prescribed limits.
Depending on the equipment, these may include normal terminal stopping devices, final terminal stopping devices, and other protective functions.
Potential deficiencies include:
- Improperly adjusted switches.
- Defective electrical contacts.
- Damaged actuating mechanisms.
- Wiring problems.
- Failure of a required protective function.
The specific testing requirements depend on the elevator’s design and the applicable code provisions.
Why owners should be concerned: These devices may rarely operate during normal service.
As a result, a problem may remain unnoticed until a prescribed test or examination identifies it.
7. Emergency Power and Firefighters’ Emergency Operation Problems
Equipment affected: Elevators equipped with these systems
Many commercial elevators incorporate firefighters’ emergency operation and, in some buildings, emergency or standby power interfaces.
Potential deficiencies include:
- Improper recall operation.
- Defective switches or controls.
- Incorrect elevator response to required signals.
- Emergency power interface problems.
- Incomplete coordination with building systems.
These functions are subject to applicable inspection, maintenance, and testing requirements. Owners should not assume that every fire service or emergency power test is part of Category 1 testing itself.
Why owners should be concerned: Some tests require coordination with building personnel, fire alarm contractors, electricians, or generator service providers.
Failure to arrange that coordination can delay testing even when the elevator equipment is otherwise ready.
8. Obsolete Safety Components and Control Equipment
Equipment affected: All elevator types
This may be one of the most significant risks for owners of older elevators.
Many elevators remain in service long after their original manufacturers discontinue certain replacement parts.
Obsolete components can include:
- Circuit boards.
- Safety relays.
- Controller components.
- Governor switches.
- Hydraulic control valves.
- Brake components.
- Specialized electrical protective devices.
An elevator does not fail Category 1 testing simply because its equipment is obsolete.
However, if a required safety function fails and the component needed to restore it is no longer available, the consequences can become substantial.
What appears to be a relatively minor electrical or mechanical problem may require an engineered replacement, controller modification, or major modernization.
Why owners should be concerned: A failed test involving obsolete equipment could result in weeks or months of downtime while alternatives are evaluated, parts are obtained, permits are processed where required, and inspections are scheduled.
This is why equipment obsolescence should be identified before a critical failure occurs.
9. Incomplete Maintenance and Testing Documentation
Equipment affected: All applicable elevators
Pennsylvania’s updated requirements place significant emphasis on testing documentation and reporting.
Under the revised regulations, Category 1 testing must be properly witnessed and documented.
Maintenance records and Maintenance Control Programs also play an important role in demonstrating that the elevator is being maintained appropriately.
Potential concerns include:
- Missing previous testing records.
- Incomplete maintenance documentation.
- Missing required test information.
- An outdated or inadequate MCP.
- Unresolved deficiencies from previous inspections.
- Missing or incorrect testing identification tags.
These issues do not necessarily constitute a mechanical failure of a Category 1 test.
However, documentation deficiencies can create separate compliance problems and complicate the testing process.
Why owners should be concerned: Even when the elevator operates correctly, incomplete documentation can result in additional administrative work, delays, and compliance concerns.
10. Deferred Maintenance That Allows Small Problems to Become Major Deficiencies
Equipment affected: All elevator types
Perhaps the greatest underlying concern is deferred maintenance.
Elevators are complex mechanical and electrical systems that require consistent preventive maintenance.
When maintenance is reduced, postponed, or inadequately performed, small problems can develop into more serious conditions.
Examples include:
- Inadequate lubrication.
- Deteriorated electrical contacts.
- Improper brake adjustments.
- Worn mechanical components.
- Contaminated hydraulic systems.
- Unresolved recurring service problems.
- Inadequate examination of safety-related devices.
Not every maintenance deficiency will cause a Category 1 failure.
However, effective maintenance reduces the likelihood that important safety-related problems will remain undetected until formal testing.
Why owners should be concerned: The cost of identifying and correcting a developing problem during routine maintenance is often substantially less than addressing it after an elevator has been removed from service.
Different Elevators, Different Testing Risks
One of the most important things for owners to understand is that Category 1 testing is not identical for every elevator.
| Equipment Type | Important Areas of Concern |
|---|---|
| Conventional hydraulic | Relief valves, hydraulic pressure and leakage, control equipment, applicable electrical protective devices |
| Roped-hydraulic | Hydraulic system components plus applicable governor, suspension-related, and safety protective devices |
| Traction | Braking systems, governor-related protective functions, terminal devices, electrical controls, and other applicable safety devices |
The exact test schedule must be established from the governing code, Pennsylvania’s adopted modifications, and the individual elevator’s design.
What Happens When a Deficiency Is Found?
Not every deficiency results in the same outcome.
Some conditions may be corrected through adjustment or minor repair.
Others may require replacement parts, additional testing, or a more extensive repair.
Serious safety-related deficiencies may prevent the elevator from remaining in operation until they are corrected.
And when the required corrective work qualifies as a major repair, replacement, or alteration, Pennsylvania’s regulations can require additional procedures before the elevator is returned to service.
Those procedures may include documentation, regulatory coordination, inspections, and approval.
For owners, the resulting downtime can extend well beyond the actual repair time.
A repair that requires only several hours of labor could still lead to an extended shutdown if parts are unavailable or regulatory approvals are required.
This is particularly important for buildings with only one elevator.
The Best Way to Avoid Surprises: Prepare Before Testing
Building owners should not wait until the day of their Category 1 test to ask whether their equipment is ready.
Instead, they should work with their maintenance provider to evaluate known problems and address deficiencies in advance.
An effective preparation strategy includes:
- Reviewing previous inspection and testing reports.
- Confirming that the equipment-specific Maintenance Control Program is being followed.
- Identifying recurring service problems.
- Evaluating known safety-related deficiencies.
- Determining whether critical replacement parts remain available.
- Reviewing maintenance contract coverage for testing and corrective work.
- Coordinating building systems and personnel needed for applicable tests.
- Establishing a contingency plan for unexpected downtime.
An independent pre-testing assessment can help identify concerns, although it cannot guarantee that the elevator will pass its required tests.
Why This Is Especially Important for Older Pennsylvania Buildings
Pennsylvania has a substantial inventory of aging commercial, residential, institutional, and industrial buildings.
Many continue to operate elevators installed decades ago.
Some have received comprehensive modernizations.
Others have been upgraded only as components fail.
This creates a wide range of equipment conditions, maintenance histories, and replacement-part availability.
For these buildings, Category 1 testing is more than an annual compliance obligation.
It is also an opportunity to evaluate the effectiveness of maintenance and identify risks that may affect future reliability.
Owners who understand those risks before testing are better positioned to manage repairs, plan capital improvements, and minimize disruptions.
The Bottom Line
Category 1 testing is intended to verify the performance of important elevator safety systems.
But the results can also reveal problems that have existed unnoticed for years.
A failed pressure relief valve, malfunctioning electrical protective device, deteriorated brake component, or obsolete controller part can quickly turn a routine testing appointment into a much larger problem.
The most expensive consequence may not be the repair itself.
It may be the extended downtime, regulatory coordination, operational disruption, and unexpected capital expenditure that follow.
The best time to identify a potential Category 1 testing problem is before the test begins—not after your elevator has been removed from service.
Building owners who take a proactive approach to maintenance, testing preparation, and equipment planning can reduce the likelihood of costly surprises.
Is Your Elevator Ready for Pennsylvania’s New Testing Requirements?
KDA Elevator Consultants provides independent elevator assessments, maintenance audits, testing oversight, code compliance consulting, and capital planning services throughout Pennsylvania and the Mid-Atlantic region.
We help building owners identify potential problems, evaluate maintenance performance, understand obsolete equipment risks, and prepare for required safety testing.
KDA Elevator Consultants
Independent Expertise. Objective Guidance. Better Elevator Decisions.
Phone: 484-995-3642
Email: john@kdaelevatorconsultants.com
Contact KDA Elevator Consultants to discuss your elevator’s Category 1 testing readiness before unexpected deficiencies become expensive problems.